|
Eye
of the Scorpion can be said to pay homage to every decade which preceded
its production. Whether by accident or design it featured elements which
belong to distinct decades of Doctor Who. That isn't to dismiss it as an
unoriginal piece of work, rather to explain why it feels both comfortably
familiar and yet disconcertingly anachronistic.
The nineteen sixties was the golden age of the historical story. They
briefly visited ancient Egypt in The Daleks Masterplan but that was a
generic Egypt, unlike the significant points in Europe's history which
were featured in such stories as the Reign of Terror or the Time Meddler.
An Aztecs style piece on the culture of ancient Egypt could've been good
though one shudders at how many times Billy would've fluffed "Erimem". I
suppose "my dear" would've sufficed. They also revisited the idea of the
young girl taken out of time. It took them all of ten minutes to give up
on Katarina and condemn her to a then-unique fate while in these more
sophisticated times the producers feel confident that they can cope with
the obvious problems that it creates.
It also features an entire episode - the second - which doesn't feature
the Doctor. Scratched by a poisoned blade, the Timelord goes off camera to
let the poison worth its way through his system. Peter Davison doesn't
sound tanned and rested when he returns in part three so we can safely
assume it wasn't a cover story for him to spend a pleasant weekend in
Brighton or Blackpool.
Peri's speech to Erimem about women being the equals of men was pure Sarah
Jane Smith. One could almost smell the musk of Aggedor as she gave the
young Pharaoh in waiting a good old women's lib lecture. It was about as
1970s as you can get without the visual possibilities of comical trousers
and hilarious shoes. Maybe it sounds so jarring to our youthful ears
because we "know" that what Peri is saying is true. It's something people
of our age have grown up knowing without having to have it explained to
us.
The action packed chariot escapade in part one would've been right up
Pertwee's street. No Doctor before or since would've been able to carry it
off with such panache. Tom would probably have managed to lasso the
runaways with his scarf and Sylv would've somehow talked them into
stopping but only Pertwee would've jumped into a chariot and raced after
the helpless Erimem.
The eighties' influence is
more obvious - Peri and the Doctor hail from that decade after all. But
one reference in particular - to Margaret Thatcher - smacks of crude
eighties Britishness. If Peri really is from 1984 then she, as an
American, would almost certainly have a positive impression of the Iron
Lady. Besides, how many other examples of the type of strong female leader
that Peri was talking about come instantly to mind? This sort of trendy
right-on joke was already being mocked as long ago as the Young Ones so
the author has no excuse unless it was a really complicated post modern
early eighties homage.
The cockney gangster villain is straight out of Lock Stock and Two Smoking
Barrels with his gruff voice and casual violence. It is odd to
ponder how some contemporary accents are ok for foreign characters to have
and others aren't. I thought he sounded like Brian Croucher but then I
thought one of the others sounded like Don "Rassilon" Warrington so what
do my ears know?
And isn't the whole mind-parasite storyline a bit New Adventurey? On TV it
would've been a rubber alien or a Carry On star behind the mucking about
with history but in a more sophisticated decade they offer a more
sophisticated solution. Except that it is a mind parasite which is
transmitted by touch which is silly. How can something pass from mind to
mind just because you have physical contact with a person? I suppose on
audio they don't have the problem that a TV production would've had where
no one on the production side would've bothered to make sure there was no
"unauthorised" touching.
|