|
The Caves Of Androzani
This
story could be described as a culmination of the increasingly harsh
universe of the Davison era, as already witnessed in the likes of
Earthshock, Warriors and Resurrection, where no-one can be guaranteed to
get out alive, and with an ever more blurred line between who the goodies
and baddies really are. It's also a portent of the unabashed cynicism of
the forthcoming Colin Baker era, with its fetishes for sadism, amorality
and genetic alteration.
The Doctor and Peri are
seriously out of their depth here, almost as soon as they stroll
innocently into the fray - really, as soon as they have both been
unknowingly infected by the raw Spectrox. Both are caught up in a world
governed by little more than ruthless self interest. Chellak and the army
are prepared to execute them for the sake of expediency, even when the
former begins to doubt their guilt of gun running. He is also persuaded by
the android Salateen to send ensign Cass on a deep penetration mission
(from which "very few return") - in effect, to have a soldier killed so as
to get rid of any potentially awkward witnesses to his having executed two
androids by mistake. Hence even Chellak's apparently straightforward
dedication to duty, which would seemingly make him the most sympathetic or
heroic supporting character, has a nasty and merciless edge.
It is arguably Morgus who
really sums up the spirit of the world the story takes place in though -
well, he and the gun running party. We soon learn, from observing his
activities on Androzani Major, that Morgus is the very worst kind of
businessman, exalting profits for himself at the expense of any kind of
public good. Essentially, if it gets him money, anything goes. Murder (the
deaths caused by the Porthcawl mines sabotage, to say nothing of the war
he is sponsoring, or the use his guns will be put to), slavery (his
proposal to have the unemployed put in labour camps) and personal
treachery (as attested by Sharaz Jek) are all quite legitimate methods to
him. He puts up little shows of morality (his asking Timmin to arrange
half minute silences for deaths he secretly caused) for appearance's sake,
but these are all uttered in a spirit of cold calculation. When the Doctor
turns up unaccountably alive in Episode Three, Morgus's instincts are that
offering him as much money as possible will get him what he wants.
Furthermore we are also
shown that the system he operates in is corrupt enough to tolerate at
least some of the cruelty and ruthlessness he advocates. The President's
"Yes, we might make that seem morally justifiable" to Morgus's proposal
about the labour camps indicates an intention to do the indefensible while
putting a false gloss on it. Forms and appearances are all that matter,
providing they conceal the ugliness beneath effectively enough.
Nevertheless, the fright
Morgus feels when he thinks the Government has discovered his gun running
role, his panicky murder of the President and his fleeing to Androzani
Minor, all help to show that he is sitting on a potential Time Bomb
throughout the height of his apparent political influence. Timmin's smug
gloating at him in the final episode when he has been reduced to the
status of an outlaw, and it becomes clear that she has known of his
illegal activities all along but simply being biding her time for the
right moment, is not only a richly satisfying turnabout in his fortunes in
the story, it also shows that his position has actually been extremely
delicate from the beginning. In the end he is no less of a common criminal
than Stotz, "just a man with a gun" as the latter observes, for all the
would-be prestige his position as a descendant of the first colonists
holds. Not, of course, that this stops Morgus from considering himself
entitled to lord it over others. His disgusted "You cowardly curs!" to
Krelper may be partly frustration but likely also reflects his need to
have creatures he can look down on.
Stotz himself has already
murdered the survivors from his crew, as well as nearly finishing Krelper
off earlier with the poison capsule (and as a writer once suggested, that
scene was probably meant to be an inversion of the scene where the Doctor
saves Peri's life by giving her some of the Spectrox cure), so there's no
doubt about his murderously competitive nature. By the time Morgus and
Stotz are prowling through the misty caves at the end, you tend to feel
it's largely a question of which one will kill the other first, especially
given the argument they have about how the Spectrox is going to be shared
out. The intention is unspoken, but the way they look at each other makes
clear how far each will go to protect their cut.
Sharaz Jek is probably the
most interesting and vividly drawn character though. Seemingly a cackling
black-clad baddie, he ultimately turns out to be probably the most
sympathetic and sensitive of them. He still has dreams of a better world
to keep him going, and probably genuinely wishes, on some level, that he
could really settle down comfortably with Peri in an idyllic and peaceful
world. He cares about beauty and the arts, and is clearly still in
mourning for his old self, when he was "comely". The fact that he feels
forced to live this fugitive subterranean existence while trying to
blackmail Major into giving him Morgus probably sharpens his loathing and
resentment all the more. His opinions on Stotz and the others ("These
petty criminals are invariably paranoid, their twisted little minds
infested with distrust and suspicion...to think that I, who once mixed
with the highest in the land, are now dependent on the very dregs of
society...the base, perverted scum who contaminate everything they
touch!") express all the yearning he has to be free of his current grim
situation and regain what he thinks Morgus has taken from him.
Hence I don't think his
obsession with Peri is primarily lustful, I think it is a case of her
youthful beauty symbolising everything he wants and believes in but which
he assumes is now denied to him. He wants to express affection, to have
someone attractive to lavish devotion on, and I find his eventual death -
collapsing into the arms of his Salateen android, who remains loyal and
faithful to him throughout - one of the most moving in the Dr Who stories.
The production values are a
bit variable, with some rather cheap looking backdrops in Morgus's
offices, and some extremely basic sets and low-fi technology on display.
Admittedly, though, the latter are probably partly intentional, to show
deprived and on the edge conditions on Androzani Minor are. The story is
also helped by some extremely assured and fluent direction which manages
to retain and build up a sense of rising tension and desperation
throughout the last two episodes in particular. There's also good use made
of montages of shots fading into each other (e.g. Jek building his
androids of the two regulars), as well as the occasional practice of slow
fades between scenes instead of direct cuts. The lighting is also
commendably dark and dingy.
Nicola Bryant is pushed
into a mostly passive role again, as she has to spend much of the story
growing progressively ill and helpless. Peri ultimately becomes the means
of the Fifth Doctor's redemption, with his struggle to save her life
eventually triumphing at the expense of his own. He has failed to save
Adric, he has had to adopt distasteful methods in his lifetime, he has had
to witness and cause many deaths on different occasions, but here he is
able to focus on rescuing and curing his one companion above anything
else, even preserving his life. The story is the Fifth Doctor's
redemption, seen most symbolically perhaps in his last desperate rush to
the TARDIS in the wilderness, Peri cradled in his arms.
Peter Davison delivers one
of his best performances in the role, managing the flippant teasing with
Jek, as well as the obsessive urgency of his need to save Peri later in
the story. He's arguably never more the innocent caught up in a cruel
world than here ("I am telling the truth, I keep telling the truth! Why is
it no-one believes me?"), and the character triumphs ultimately even in
death, having been ultimately the only one in the story to have acted
entirely out of altruism and compassion with no base or selfish instinct
at all. Whereas in Resurrection he is never really in a position to make
good his claim that he does "not accept" the "universal way of life"
involving warfare and killing that Davros describes, here he does manage
to emphatically deny it by his own unselfish actions, which do generate a
positive result. His values have won a sort of victory, with Peri's life
having been saved, in comparison with the self-destructive nothingness
that has resulted on Androzani Minor.
|