|
Boom Town
The
most important aspect of this story is its attempt to examine the nature
of crime and rehabilitation versus capital punishment within the context
of the series. Its plot trappings are relatively trivial and mainly a
means to an end.
Blon Fel-Fotch, the
Slitheen masquerading as Margaret Blaine, manages to take over the story,
despite having been captured by the Doctor's party, by raising this issue
and pushing it to the forefront. Is the death penalty (which she faces on
being returned home) a fair punishment for her crimes, or is it a form of
legalised murder, which reduces all those complicit in the process to her
level (her reply to Mickey's accusation that she deserves it: "And that
makes you better than me how, exactly?"). Her asking if any of them would
be prepared to do the deed themselves is a point often brought up by
opponents of capital punishment, and her challenge for any of the group to
look her in the eye (apart from reminding me of the "Look me in the
eye...end my life" line used in The Happiness Patrol and Battlefield) is
implicitly a means of daring them to prove that they are not squeamish
hypocrites.
While posing this dilemma
is certainly quite a brave experiment for a series which so often resolves
a threat by having it blown up, killed or destroyed in some way (the very
next story for example), it's notable that the Doctor remains resolute and
unfazed throughout. He is never in any doubt that the correct course of
action is to hand Blon over to her species' retribution, and seems
unwilling to take any other option seriously. Even though Russell T Davies
is on record as opposing capital punishment, and having written this
episode to highlight that, it seems very unlikely to me that anyone
watching the story would extend that belief to the Doctor. His attitude is
clearly that she deserves no better and is too dangerous to be allowed to
live. He utters the hand-washing phrase "I don't make the law" at one
stage, although given the previous form of this Doctor alone (eg his
willingness to allow Cassandra to die in front of him in The End Of The
World) it seems unlikely that witnessing her execution would particularly
perturb him.
More significantly the
story does very little to suggest that he is wrong, and quite a great deal
to back up his point of view. Blon's claim to have reformed is plainly
insincere, when she has not only been shown to be still murdering her way
through any obstacles to her plans at the beginning of the story, but is
still trying to make several attempts on the Doctor's life during their
restaurant meal (these latter are slightly cartoonish and smack a little
of one of Bugs Bunny's and Elmer Fudd's surrealist duels). Furthermore the
entire restaurant visit turns out to have been nothing more than a ruse on
Blon's part to allow time for her contingency plan to take effect.
Of course, the one
exception to this is Blon's sparing the life of a journalist who is
threatening to cause trouble, after the latter reveals that she is
pregnant. It is as though the mentions of family temporarily depress her
due to the reminder of her own bereavement. Apparently feeling unable (for
the time being) to visit such an experience an another she lets her go.
Yet this fails to impress the Doctor, and his careful analysis of why this
is just a token gesture rather than any proof of rejection inspires Blon's
accusation that only someone who was as much as a killer as her could
understand those thought patterns.
This brings into focus the
vigilante nature of heroes. There's no doubt that the Doctor does have a
great deal of blood on his hands, considering the various ways he has
despatched or defeated enemies of his in the past. So he could indeed be
said to have acted the role of executioner before now (what other way
could you describe the Armageddon he was apparently forced to unleash to
end the Time War, for that matter?). But while there can undoubtedly be an
obsessive and ruthless side to the more dedicated justice-seekers of
fiction (Sherlock Holmes is a good example), and there is also the old
adage about not gazing too long into the abyss lest the abyss gaze back up
at you, it can be seen that Blon's and the Doctor's motives and morality
are very different. One is acting purely from self-interest and cares not
a jot for how many deaths or casualties might result from her plans. The
other is, on this occasion, genuinely trying to tidy up a mess leftover
from the past, and acting in the hope of saving lives. Killing is a last
resort, only to be employed if it means preventing still more deaths,
which is how the Doctor justifies Blon's execution (ensuring she will have
no further victims).
The story is obviously
intended as an analogy over concerns about extraditing criminals to
countries where they face execution, which is probably why it tends to shy
away from addressing some of the other options available in the fiction.
For instance, the Doctor could take Blon to a place and time far removed
from the story's setting, where she could never be found, and be too
isolated to threaten anyone (he makes an offer along those lines to the
Terileptil leader in The Visitation, who is in a similar situation to Blon
in some ways). This solution obviously isn't available in the real world,
although neither is the one eventually used. Furthermore, giving her a
chance to live her life again does beg a question or two. It does seem
somewhat unfair or unsatisfying that Blon will get the chance to live
again when none of her (many) victims will. That said, it does also help
set up the resolution used two episodes later, so could be said to serve
that purpose too.
Other than this, the story
is notable for progressing the crew dynamics a little further. Mickey is
not particularly impressed with Captain Jack on his first meeting, and
it's possible to sympathise to some extent with his bored disgust at the
self-supportive hand slapping antics of the crew. However, he also
demonstrates a greater ability than before in the series to give as good
as he gets and seems to quickly settle down into a friendly closeness with
the other three. Indeed, the scene where they are laughing and joking
together in the cafe is something of a brief highpoint in the characters'
interrelations, showing them to be thoroughly relaxed in their own
company.
The episode turns out to be
quite a strong one for Mickey ultimately, as he gets the chance to round
on Rose for taking him for granted so much (which she has done at the very
start of the episode, expecting him to come running to Cardiff as soon as
she asks), which shocks her into a guilty denial of having intended any
slight to him. Her recounting of some of her off-world adventures with the
Doctor mean nothing to him, and Rose is still left with some feelings of
guilt at the end, while he is prowling the night streets and deliberately
keeping out of her sight. The problem, ultimately, is that they have each
chosen mutually incompatible ways of living but don't seem willing to
fully face the fact that this is bound to alter their relationship. Rose
wants to be free to travel with the Doctor as much as she likes, Mickey
cannot abide the thought, and yet the two of them remain physically
attracted to each other, and Rose's first instinct, when back in her own
era, is to call on Mickey for help. Just as, for all his half-hearted
attempts to acquire other girlfriends, Mickey still really just wants Rose
back. So it's not surprising that she feels somewhat attracted by the
prospect of a fresh start herself at the end.
The story is carried to a
large extent by Annette Badland's charismatic performance in the role of
the main adversary. The script gives her more chance to show off her
acting range than her previous story, and she manages to slip between the
whimsical "Ooh, silly old me"-style ingeniousness put on for her
playacting as Margaret and the cold-eyed vicious snarling of her
character's true persona, with apparent ease. The lighting helps too, with
one particular shot in the TARDIS lending her expression a decided
malevolence. She also carries off the "Teleporting" scene well (one of the
better attempts at comic relief in this season).
Although a fairly slight
story, it's quite a thoughtful one which turns out to be more interesting
than it might seem initially, and deserves some credit as a
well-intentioned morality play within the series' format.
|