One of the most surprising things about the decline of Doctor Who
in the 1980s is the speed with which it happened- there’s less than six
months from The Five Doctors to the abortive cancellation
announcement- and looking at Target’s 1984 list, there’s a confidence in
the series and the brand which would never quite be the same again. And
yet again, the output splits fairly evenly down the middle into the
adaptations of the Fifth Doctor’s stories, bringing all Peter Davison’s
stories up to and including ‘Frontios’ (barring the two-parters) into
print, with an interesting selection of tales from earlier eras- in fact,
given the fairly comprehensive approach with which the Third and Fourth
Doctors’ stories had been adapted down the years, of the four "previous
Doctor" stories, three of the four were from the 1960s and only ‘Inferno’
had been made in colour. It may well be deliberate that of the stories
adapted, all feature companions who had been revisited in ‘The Five
Doctors’- Susan, Jamie (twice), Zoe, Liz and the Brigadier- while ‘The
Dominators’ had also had an airing at the Longleat celebration. For the
second year running, Terrance Dicks was limited to four entries in the
range- Ian Marter making his annual contribution with ‘The Dominators’,
while Peter Grimwade, Barbara Clegg, John Lucarotti and Christopher H.
Bidmead adapted their own scripts. Special mention, however, must be
reserved for Gerry Davis, making a return to the Tagret range after
several years to adapt ‘The Highlanders’, a set of scripts which (if the
records are to be believed) Davis more or less wrote himself, and which in
the absence of much visual reference material, he was surely best placed
to turn into prose.
After a few experiments of limited success, by the end
of 1984 the photographic element had been firmly ditched from the covers.
‘Mawdryn Undead’ must surely be the least inspiring, using a dull
photograph of Peter Davison rather than attempting to give the prospective
buyer a visual key to the story- when a recent story is involved, the
point is surely to remind the casual purchaser which story we’re looking
at here. ‘Kinda’ is scarcely better, however Target clearly wanted to
enable readers to identify the current Doctor’s adventures and so next
attempted to incorporate a photograph of Peter Davison into the series’
logo. This must have been particularly tricky with low-tech 1980s graphic
design resources and detracts from two rather good covers, however the
experimen can’t have been a success as the photos were dropped entirely
for ‘The Dominators’ (although it would have been nice to have had one
merging Patrick Troughton with the logo) and ‘Warriors of the Deep’ is a
stronger cover precisely because it’s missing. Nick Spender’s interlude at
the end of the year brought a different approach- although ‘Inferno’ is
very much in Skilleter’s style, ‘The Aztecs’ relies on a description of
Tlotoxl from the book and presumably Spender’s own research rather than
the televised story, and it’s only in retrospect with the release of
certain BBC photographs from the relevant productions that we can see just
how much Spender did work from these resources. In contrast, Andrew
Skilleter’s style focuses firstly on the monster or other dominant image
from the story in question, and then setting it into an appropriate and
evocative background.
So there’s an air of confidence about 1984’s releases;
the series (and Peter Davison) remained popular and the first steps in a
systematic adaptation of the series’ buried past are generally successful.
Adapting ‘The Highlanders’ in particular must have been no mean feat, even
for Gerry Davis- with a handful of photos and his own 17-year-old memories
of the story, he still turns in a creditable rendition of a story which
remains missing from the archives. And with a new Doctor, no doubt Target
set about 1985 in much the same spirit, although as it would turn out, the
1985 list would become very interesting indeed...