Silver Nemesis

It’s easy to make fun of Silver Nemesis. Actually, it isn’t because people just don’t like it. Some people even hate it. You’ll see someone suggest it as a DVD release (perchance to tie in with the return of some metal monsters) and people are all "God no" and "Don’t let it happen" and "I really hope they don’t". Which is werid as I was under the impression that free will wasn’t an illusion and so one could choose whether to buy a particular DVD. With that off my chest I’ll confess to having watched la Nemesis for the first time in ages recently and found it to be more than just the simpleton little brother of Remembrance of the Daleks. I found it inspired so much more than just feelings of irrational disgust. It inspired… things.

  1. The scene where the skinheads ask if Peinforte and Richard are social workers is so inexplicable that one has to assume that it was intended that different people speak the lines to different recipients in different circumstances and possibly in a different series.

  2. The writer claims (with some pride) that the Cybermen were included because it was the silver anniversary and they are silver. I suppose if it had been the wool anniversary (7 years) they would've hired Giles Brandreth.

  3. When Richard says his mistress has "a little Greek" am I the only one to imagine Stavros hiding beneath her skirts?

  4. Why do we live in a world where you can buy a talking Slitheen doll but not a singing Lady Peinforte? "All that is... and all that was..."

  5. JNT hated the sonic screwdriver and K9 because they were too good at resolving any problem which came along. He was however quite happy to allow devices such as the modified tape deck which just appeared at the start of the story, solved everything and were never used again.

  6. Once the Cybermen were invincible giants whose only weakness was the blasting of non-corrosive gold dust into their breathing unit. Now they have become buffoons who would fall over if someone played "Gold" by Spandau Ballet.

  7. There is the inexplicable scene between De Flores and the Cyberleader where they talk about the Cyber-weakness to arrows made of gold. Everyone’s favourite Nazi claims that humans aren’t susceptible to that weakness. Ok, we don’t fall over if someone tosses a coin at us (unless you’re a footballer) but we still kinda die if shot with an arrow.

  8. When the Doctor activates the validium he and Ace keep flapping on about chess moves. Is this an attempt to sound clever or just a way of distracting us from the fact that the Cybermen literally stand there and quietly panic?

  9. Speaking of Cybermen, who polished them? While waiting around in space until they detected the Nemesis did they get bored and decide to buff each other up or did they pick up an infomercial and think "That could be useful"?

  10. They rather skim over how Lady Peinforte travelled through time. Yes, the arrow helped her but the Doctor just mumbles something about "black magic" and carries on with whatever he was doing. Pertwee would’ve been appalled.

  11. You can’t help but love the scenes in the rich American lady’s car. She and Richard are having a confused but amiable conversation and suddenly Lady Peinforte blurts out "All things will be mine". She gets a "aye aye – the drunk’s woken up" look before Mrs Remington carries on talking.

  12. I don’t get jazz. I never have. I think it was only included to make Keff McCulloch sound good.

  13. De Flores has a very smug sidekick. I was glad when he got killed and not because he was a Nazi. He could’ve been the owner of a really nice cake shop and I would still have been pleased when he was eradicated. Smug faced fool.

  14. Why is the Doctor surprised when he discovers that the Cyber-fleet has been hiding? He knew they were there and knew he couldn’t see them. It seems rather obvious if you think about it in that amount of detail.

  15. And how does he trick them into revealing themselves just by twiddling the bass, treble and balance knobs?

  16. And isn’t the Cyber-fleet just the least threatening looking battle fleet ever? Boxy looking space ships with lots of flashing lights. It is actually less intimidating than the cotton-reel space fleet seen at the end of season 2 of Blake’s 7.

  17. It is weird how the 17th century mathematician and the 20th century computer (both of which work out the path of the Nemesis) look equally antiquated to modern eyes. That blocky, flashing text? Eugh. Give me a quill and a death sentence any day.

  18. The Doctor must be having a real off day if he thinks that an audience with the Queen would help the situation. Because obviously she’d believe him and do what he said. But of course we’ve all seen the documentary on the video and know that the whole Windsor Castle thing was just an excuse for the hilarious wellies gag.

  19. Fiona Walker chews the scenery (painful considering it was all location work) as few have ever chewed it before. Her final moments – screaming and jumping into the asteroid – earn her a place in the Crowden wing of the Doctor Who hall of fame.

  20. The dénouement in the hanger is somewhat strange in that the Doctor tells the Cybermen what he’s going to do and they still fall for it. The jets of fire incinerating the two guards is cool though.

  21. The secret passage in Lady Peinforte’s tomb appears to be cunningly disguised as a door.

  22. It has the worst video cover ever. The story’s reputation is unfair - I rather like it – but the cover is a foil-pas of the worst kind. It’s also green (which isn't silver).

  23. Thanks to that American documentary I always think of him as "Jer-RARD" Murphy rather than simply "Gerard" Murphy. Equally I always imagine the late Gary Downie as a camp and gaily-bespectacled chap with a wellie fetish.

  24. Some of the location work was apparently done on the site of what would become the millennium dome. A folly upon a folly. A poetic tribute to two men whose misplaced enthusiasm made laughing stocks of two important anniversaries.

I hope it does come out on the shiny disc. It isn't massively good but it isn't terrible either. Be honest - would you rather a "new series" fan watched "The Happiness Patrol" or "Paradise Towers" or "Silver Nemesis"? It may be glossy and vacant and often illogical but it is one of the less embarrassing McCoy stories.