
Newly verified evidence in blue
Castrovalva
 |
Following the regeneration, the
Doctor's hair is brown and yet the fake Davison is blonde.
|
 |
JNT credits the real Davison as
"Doctor Who" in Logopolis but cannot bring himself to do the same for
the fake and so credits him simply as "The Doctor".
|
 |
The Doctor immediately heads for
the "Zero Room" - the name clearly implying that there are zero genuine
Doctors in the episode.
|
 |
The Zero Room later becomes a
casket - the fake Davison in a casket is clearly a sign that the real
thing had passed away.
|
 |
"Portreeve" is a typically JNT
anagram mixed with a cunning acronym and obviously means "Peter ROEV" or
"Peter Ran Out of Essential Vitality"
|
 |
The Tardis crew jettison 25% of
the ship in order to escape the hydrogen in rush. Or, to put it another
way, one quarter of them went away during the Big Bang. Clearly a
reference to Mr Davison's unfortunate departure.
|
 |
The cricketing costume was not
merely a coincidence - clearly they chose a game where two men play
effectively as one to symbolise the Davison name and image combining
with his lookalike's body.
|
 |
The philosophical discussion of
"if" places great emphasis on I.F. as separeate letters. This is
obviously meant to signify Intercourse Fatality which was Mr Davison's
tragic means of demise.
|
 |
The Doctor refers at the very end
to a "shipshape" team. Much of a ship is under the water just as a very
important part of the Tardis crew was actually underground.
|
 |
The scene where the Doctor finds a
bottle marked "the solution" and comments that he wishes it was is a
direct reference to John Nathan Turner briefly turning to drink after
Davison's death and his subsequent orders to hush the whole thing up.
|
 |
Tegan saying the words "enormous
thrust" with such emphasis do not need any explanation.
|
 |
The Doctor floating in the Zero
Room is a metaphor for Davison floating up to heaven.
|
 |
The BBC video cover for Castrovalva blatantly features
several different Peter Davisons
|
Four to Doomsday
 |
The message of this story is "people aren't always what
they look like" and it was the first to be recorded after Mr Davison's
replacement.
|
 |
"I would never interfere with your monopticons" says the
fake Davison, the script implying this isn't the Doctor because the
Doctor always interferes with things.
|
 |
The name "Bigon" sounds like bygone which is a thing
that is in the past, just like Peter Davison.
|
 |
The Doctor has a magnifying glass which is a tool used
by television detectives when they are looking for clues. This was a
deliberate clue that people should look in the story for clues.
|
 |
The Aborigine thinks the ship is going to heaven. This
is a deliberate reference to Peter Davison having lived a good and
sin-free life.
|
 |
Monarch is clearly intended to be the autocratic JNT and
he says clearly "We need doubt" which was Nathan Turner's attitude to
the Davison cover up.
|
 |
Many uses of the word "Recreational" draws our attention
to it. It is blatantly a twisting of L.A. Recreation or Late Artiste
Recreation which is a BBC-ish term for smuggling a lookalike into studio
to replace a dead actor.
|
 |
The Doctor floating in space is obviously meant to
signify Peter Davison floating about in the heavens.
|
 |
The Doctor goes into a trance to save air - his furious
panting near the point of death is a clear indicator.
|
 |
The Doctor survives floating in space thanks to his
skill and experience with cricket balls. This is clearly meant to link
the Doctor being alive and balls in the mind of the viewers.
|
 |
The video cover features Peter Davison's face surrounded
by clouds.
|
 |
Peter Davison doesn't even feature on the 1991 Target
reprint. Make of that what you will.
|
 |
The string is a blatant clue as
string represents the three Fates of classical Greek Mythology who weave
the thread of our lives and then cut it when we die.
|
Kinda
 |
The various mentions of boxes are a clear reference to
coffins into which dead people are put.
|
 |
Karuna: 'How many fathers do the "not we" have?'
Doctor: 'Well, on the whole, one!'
The implication is clearly that it could be two where a duplicate has been hired.
|
 |
Doctor: 'An apple a day keeps the... Ah.' This joke
speaks for itself and requires no explanation as it is obvious that
the production team that went to so much trouble to find a replacement
Doctor most certainly don't want him to keep away, apple or no apple.
|
 |
The video cover has two significant clues - firstly
that the Doctor doesn't even bother to look like Peter Davison and
secondly we see Tegan laughing a mocking laugh just over the "Starring
Peter Davison" caption. She doesn't believe it either.
|
 |
Even the name is significant - "Doctor Who : Kinda"
meaning it's kind of Doctor Who. Almost but not quite the real thing.
|
 |
JNT started the rumour that this story was written by
Kate Bush as it is an anagram of "beak shut" implying the secrecy they
were under.
|
 |
The two ghost people Tegan sees at the beginning of
her dream talk at length about how you cannot believe something just
because you see it. This scene is sandwiched, unsubtly, by two
featuring the faux-Davison.
|
 |
Hindle actually says "Doctor - you don't fool me I'm
afraid" but since Kinda was a parable (or something) the Powers that
Be assumed it meant something deeper and more philosophical than a
squalid management cover up to prevent a sleazy tabloid sex'n'death
exposé. |
The Visitation
 |
"I feel as if you've just killed an old friend" says
the Doctor when the sonic screwdriver is destroyed. Those were the
words allegedly spoken by JNT to Sandra Dickinson the first time he
saw her after Davison passed away.
|
 |
JNT cleverly managed to disguise the presence of Death
in this story by covering him with costume jewellery. BBC Management
were shallow enough not to see past the glittering gems.
|
 |
The DVD cover famously had a picture of the real Peter
Davison replaced by a photo of the impostor. But, being the BBC, it
was done rather badly.
|
 |
The Doctor is seen to pass through a wall in the
manner of a ghost.
|
 |
The Android is killed using a very sexual vibrating
machine just as Peter Davison was (his, of course, answered to the
name "Sandra")
|
 |
The end of episode two has the Doctor facing death and
he remarks "not again". Some claim this refers to Four to Doomsday's
identical cliffhanger but I believe he is empathising with JNT having
to find a third lookalike were the replacement to perish.
|
 |
Eric Saward wrote a very lengthy opening sequence
which did not feature the Doctor. This is clearly a subtle hint that
Doctor Who could manage without the real Peter Davison.
|
 |
The director for this story was Peter Moffat, Peter
Davison's real name was Peter Moffat. Imagine how confusing it would
be to have two Peter Moffats in one studio. It would be bloody
insanity. Luckily it never happened.
|
 |
The addition of "Pudding Lane" to the script was
Nathan Turner's decision. He was, by this stage, beginning to enjoy
the job of concealing the deception and "Pudding Lane" is an anagram
of "Add Glen I Pun" which is a definite clue (assuming the
replacement's name was Glen).
|
Black Orchid
 |
Someone pretends to be the Doctor as happened in real
life.
|
 |
The story is based around a handy duplicate of Nyssa
which is the important difference which enabled the storyline to get
past the BBC's cover up department.
|
 |
Black is the colour of death and orchids are flowers.
Flowers are closely related to both sex and funerals. Both of which
occurred near the end of Peter Davison's life.
|
 |
The fact that JNT brought the rarely seen two-part
story back is a definite clue which signifies the cutting short of Mr
Davison's life.
|
 |
Peter Davison played Tristan in "All Creatures Great
and Small" and got a reputation as being both bland and young. It is
therefore no coincidence that "Black Orchid" is a phonetic spoonerism
for "Lack bore kid"
|
 |
People spend a good chunk of the tale wearing masks
which is a direct reference to the plastic surgery that the
faux-Davison probably had before taking the job.
|
 |
The Amazon chappie has his bottom lip sticking out.
This is what children do when they're really sad at the death of a
pet.
|
 |
"Terence Dudley" - writer of this story - is an
anagram of "celery dud teen" which implies that the Davison
replacement was even younger than the original.
|
 |
Stock footage was used of steam trains from a
documentary series called "God's Wonderful Railway" which has to be a
reference to going to heaven which is, as previously mentioned, the
saintly Mr Davison went. |
Earthshock
 |
The Cyberleader says "This one calls himself the
Doctor" instead of "This is the one called the Doctor" which obviously
is intended to suggest that it is not the real Doctor.
|
 |
The black androids are clearly
intended to represent mourners at a funeral and serve no real purpose
in the story that couldn't be achieved with two Cybermen and a can of
paint.
|
 |
Earthshock is an anagram of
"cork the ash" which implies Davison was cremated, possibly during
production, which is why no one has ever found his grave.
|
 |
"Peter Davison" on the
Earthshock commentary says that Beryl Reid appeared on his This Is
Your Life because there were so few other guests. This is not
surprising as he'd only been Peter Davison for a few months and how
many friends can you make in that time?
|
 |
The Doctor's speech about things
that make life beautiful inexplicably includes "eating a well prepared
meal" at the expense of "having sex with a pretty blonde" which we
presume is because of the way Peter Davison passed away.
|
 |
The silent credits over the
remains of a star are too much of a coincidence given that the real
Peter Davison was a household name.
|
 |
All the women in this story are
made to look either manly or frumpy to avoid "Peter Davison" becoming
aroused and potentially leaving them with yet another literal stiff to
dispose of. |
Time-Flight
 |
"Kalid" is an
anagram of "Dalik" which is obviously meant to imply a badly produced
copy of a Doctor Who favourite.
|
 |
Concorde is the most
phallic of planes so it disappearing shortly after a supersonic bang
isn't the most subtle allusion to Mr Davison's expiration.
|
 |
The final scene - a
woman left behind by Peter Davison - clearly replicates Sandra
Dickinson's abandonment following Peter's athletic demise.
|
 |
The entire story
revolves around people imagining things that aren't real and believing
themselves to be doing things which are more exciting than what they
are actually doing. An obvious allusion to sex during marriage which
is what killed Peter Davison.
|
 |
Towards the end of
one episode, Kalid tries to prevent Nyssa and Tegan reaching the end
of their journey by imagining the presence of Matthew Waterhouse. A
trick Peter Davison may well have tried and which could've contributed
to his amazing stamina on that fatal night.
|
 |
The Master's Tardis
is a large and apparently lifeless column. A miraculous power source
needs to be transported to its heart in order for it to come back to
life. You don't need to be Poirot to see the hidden truth in that plot
point.
|
 |
"Plasmatons" is an
anagram of "a.m. pant loss" which undoubtedly refers to the sudden
silence which befell the bedroom in the early hours when Davison's
ecstatic groans were snuffed out.
|
 |
Yet again the
BBC video cover shows Peter Davison surrounded by clouds as though he
art in heaven. Which no doubt is as he lead a blameless (if not
entirely stainless) life.
|
 |
The
Doctor programming an inhibition factor into the temporal limiter was
a clear reference to JNT's wish that Peter Davison had shown more
inhibitions and not undertaken the sexual odyssey that was to so limit
his own temporality. |
|